What is the Difference between Pickling and Passivation?

Pickling and passivation are both chemical processes used to treat metal surfaces, but they serve different purposes and involve different chemicals.

Pickling

Pickling is a metal treatment process primarily used to remove impurities such as rust, scale, and oxides from the metal surface. This is achieved by immersing the metal in an acidic solution. The acid dissolves the impurities, leaving a clean metal surface. Along with impurities, some metallic atoms of the base metal are removed, resulting in heavy metals being present in the pickling waste stream. Pickling is often used as a preparatory step before further processing like coating, plating, or passivation.

Advantages of Pickling

  • Removes heavy oxidation, heat tint, and weld discoloration
  • Provides a uniform surface appearance
  • Restores surface chemistry to its mill finished condition

Disadvantages of Pickling*

  • Environmental and health hazards due to the use of strong acids
  • Risk of damaging the metal if not properly controlled

Passivation

Passivation, on the other hand, is a chemical process that enhances corrosion resistance by promoting the uniform formation of a thin, inert oxide layer on the metal surface. Passivation is also accomplished using acid solutions; however, the chemistry is significantly less strong than pickling. Passivation acids, typically nitric or citric acid, remove free iron or other metallic contaminants from the surface, allowing a chromium oxide layer to form across the whole metal surface. This layer acts as a protective barrier against corrosion. Passivation is often used as a finishing process after pickling or other treatments.

Advantages of Passivation

  • Increases corrosion resistance by forming a uniform protective oxide layer
  • Reduces the risk of product contamination
  • Extends the maintenance intervals of metal components
  • Does not alter the appearance or surface finish of the metal

Disadvantages of Passivation*

  • Handling of acids and disposal of waste can be challenging
  • Can be ineffective if the metal surface is not properly cleaned beforehand. See ASTM A967 Section 5.3.2 for more.

Key Differences

Purpose:  Pickling is primarily for cleaning and removing impurities, while passivation is for enhancing corrosion resistance.

Process:  Pickling uses stronger acids to remove metallic surface layers, whereas passivation uses milder acids to form a protective oxide layer. Aggressive pickling chemistries remove heavy metals from the surface and generate hazardous waste while passivating chemistries are designed to generate nonhazardous waste.

Effect on Metal:  Pickling can change the appearance and properties of the metal more significantly, often leaving a dull finish. Passivation does not change the appearance but improves corrosion resistance.

In summary, pickling and passivation are complementary processes often used together to clean and protect metal surfaces, with pickling serving as a preparatory cleaning step and passivation as a finishing step to enhance corrosion resistance. By understanding and implementing these processes, metals can achieve superior protection and extended service life, minimizing costly quality issues due to corrosion.

*When not performed by a professional chemical cleaning provider

Metal Applicable Specification or Standard Chemistry Description
Austenitic Stainless Steel ASTM A380 Intensified citric acid, Intensified nitric acid
Ferritic / Martensitic Stainless Steel ASTM A380 Intensified citric acid, Intensified nitric acid
Carbon Steel SSPC-SP 8 Citric acid, Phosphoric acid, Sulfuric acid, Hydrochloric acid
Nickel Alloys ASTM A380 Intensified citric acid, Intensified nitric acid
Titanium Alloys ASTM B600 Intensified nitric acid
Copper Alloys Citric acid

Recent
Blog Posts

Picture of Bradley Hostetler

Bradley Hostetler

Bradley Hostetler has joined Astro Pak filling the role of senior metallurgist in Astro Pak’s Technical Services Group. Bradley holds a Bachelor’s degree in Materials Engineering from California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo and a Master’s in Materials Science from Carnegie Mellon University. He comes from the metal production industry and has both research and work experience in steel and specialty alloy melting. Bradley has experience participating and presenting at various AIST (Association for Iron and Steel Technology) and NACE (National Association of Corrosion Engineers) conferences during his time as a student.

Recent
Blog Posts